Madison Avenue Pizza

We came, we waited, we ordered. It came out piping hot and tantalizing. We did our best just for the challenge of trying (but not the actual challenge)! We were a group of four brave souls on a pizza journey! Some of us fought but were deterred shortly after. With two remaining to try and tackle this beast! We made it half way through but the beast bested us! We may not have won but we were still winners!!! With that said the pizza was DAMN tasty and would go back just to get more even if we did leave with four 14” boxes full of pizza.

This is a highly recommended establishment on my end. Talked to the owner and they make everything from scratch. From the dressing to the bread for the subs to real hand cut fries. This is pretty impressive for a pizzeria. And to top it off, everything was excellent quality. We got the Garlic Knots to start along with a side of Meatballs. Both were great. Then we got some of those Hand Cut Fries with House-made Ranch and we were impressed. I’m not a big “Ranch Guy” (my son is) but I really liked this with the Fries. Then came the Sicilian Pizza, and this thing was huge. Fantastic sweet sauce, top quality cheeses (not just mozzarella in this beast). Highly recommend this pizza. Service was super friendly and seemed genuinely happy to work there (can’t say that about every restaurant). Lastly, this restaurant has a cool vibe with the rock and roll icons painted on the wall, large central bar, outside seating and good music playing throughout the night. Loud enough to enjoy but not too loud that you need to struggle to talk to the people at your table. Definitely going to return to try some wings and the Cheesesteak. I love when locally owned businesses do things the right way.

New in town from Miami and drove here to try it first time after seeing some promising reviews. I had an amazing Philly cheesesteak with onion, sweet pepper, and cherry pepper. Side of tater tots. Both delicious and can feed two people. The two old fashioned cocktails I had were excellent. So many restaurants mess up this classic simple drink so I was pleasantly surprised at how great it was. Service team was nice and attentive. It was late when I came but would like to enjoy a game day or busier bar day to compare. I’ll be back. Great job guys!

We stopped here after an entire day at the beach and it didn’t disappoint, place was packed but we sat outside and they were pretty quick. We ordered Garlic knots, Old school cheese pie, the New York supreme and an Old school with pepperoni and bacon. Everything was really good and waitress was nice and attentive.

What an amazing visit. This place was absolutely . We had a great time here, with the server, the pizza was spot on, the service was spot on. Thank you Chef for hooking them picky eaters I brought and making the pizza for different flavors! Huge kudos to you all!

I visited Madison Avenue Pizza in Tampa and it totally lived up to the hype. This spot has a chill, laid-back vibe perfect for grabbing a slice or two with friends. I started with the toasted beef ravioli, and I was honestly surprised by how good it was. Crispy on the outside, warm and cheesy on the inside it made a great little appetizer before the main event. Now let’s talk pizza. I had the Roasted Italian Pizza and the Meat Lovers, and both were solid. The Roasted Italian had a really nice balance of flavor not too heavy, but still super tasty with all the toppings. The Meat Lovers was my favorite loaded with cheese and all the meats without feeling greasy or overwhelming. Every bite was satisfying. The service was friendly, and everything came out hot and fresh. If you’re in Tampa and craving pizza that’s flavorful, filling, and made right, I’d definitely recommend checking this place out. It’s the kind of spot that makes you want to come back and try the whole menu.

We took a family vacation to Dunedin Fl. After reading reviews we decided to give this place a shot. This place has phenomenal pizza. Great environment & staff seemed friendly. We got our 1/2 pepperoni/cheese with extra cheese pizza & Meat Lovers Stromboli to go. We absolutely loved the food & would definitely would recommend the pizza & Stromboli. Stromboli was huge along with the 18” pizza. It fed 2 adults & 3 kids with leftovers.

Some may say driving an hour out for pizza is wild behavior but I’m wilder ! We came from Tampa to eat here and Madison Avenue Pizza exceed my expectations! The best pizza and philly cheese sub I’ve had yet!! The bartender was so nice and made great drinks. The wings were good also. I was so full after the pizza, wings and sub but somehow found room for the delicious s’mores pizza! What an experience! I highly recommend this place!